Feb 8, 2019-

My eight-year-old son often asks me, “Mom why do all our relatives live in Nepal while we are the only ones living here in America?” I try to console him with the narrative many migrant families relay to their children: We moved here from Nepal when he was a toddler ‘in search of new opportunities’.

During his ‘Curious George’ phase, he would ask multiple questions about family—and, in the process, would get jumbled up in details about his maternal and paternal sides. I had drawn up a large family tree and tangibly shown him our large family, one by one. When we grew up in Nepal, we never had to ask our parents these questions because we automatically knew who constituted family. As many of us know and have experienced, living in another country permanently alters you. You will never be the same and will never see things the same way again.

I have read many articles on going back to the home country after living many years abroad and my story is nothing different, but just one more point of view. Recently, an article by Rabindra Mishra of the Bibeksheel Sajha Party and his home coming story moved me. It made me ponder: what is the purpose of living here, struggling each day, when back home our family is missing us each day? We are missing out all the seemingly minute things we can do in our own country—where our slightest contributions can have gigantic impacts. As I’ve delved in conversation on this issue with many people, I’ve realised that I’m not alone.

“Eventually, it is really something only you can decide,” someone recently told me. Half a decade has passed in the blink of an eye and my husband and I often debate going back. As the only son in the family, I’ve sensed that he always wanted to return to ensure that his parents were taken care of. But to lay my truths bare, I wasn’t certain of returning, because the pressures of being a typical daughter-in-law in a joint family were taking a toll on me. But at the same time, I always felt that it was possible to extend support to our family from the outside.

When I moved here, I had it relatively easier than most, as my sister had also moved with me. In the beginning, it felt as simple as moving from one house to the other. The real struggle emerged when we had to survive on our own. Starting over from ground zero is not easy. Cutting a long story short: we managed, we survived, and we moved on. No matter what, we never lost connection with our families and friends back in Nepal and I have sought to ensure that my kids knew where our roots are and where we come from. Some of my good friends often ask me to come back. They point to my newly-gained skills and often tell me that they may be more valuable in Nepal.

When my mother lived with us here in America, she felt sorry for my husband who worked almost 18 hours a day at one time. Seeing us brave severely cold weather to scrape layers of snow from our cars and driving to work on slippery roads almost made her cry. She firmly requested us to move back. She’d often tell me, “You might be happier living a more humble life in your home country instead of a luxurious life in a strange land with different culture, different people and that lingering feeling of being an outsider,” she said.

Obviously, we can't demand or expect from Nepal the kind of infrastructure and facilities we have access to here in America. But Nepal is still the place we were born and raised. I have always wanted to go back--be it for my parents, who are all by themselves, for my kids, who won't even know our own family members if they stay here, and for our society, which needs people who can voice change.

So, in a nutshell: I am mentally preparing myself and my kids for what life in Nepal can be like. Rather than proscribing to the ‘grass is greener on the other side’ narrative, I always like to think that the ‘grass is greener where you water it’. I hear so many friends trying to muddle through the mess of deciding whether to go back or not. If they're going to have to take their watering can with them wherever they go, then why not take it to your own country?

This isn’t to say that you should stay where you are if you’re feeling unsatisfied with your work or realise that you want to have face-to-face interactions with your family on a more frequent basis, but it’s a healthy way to reframe the decision. So, gathering up all these clues, I have decided to move back to my own country where I belong and where (I hope I will) find my true calling. All these decisions should, in my opinion, be based on a number of aspects, including how easily you can make a living, how clearly you know the present realities of Nepal, how risk-averse or risk-taking you are and whether you have dependents or not. At the end of the day, only you can do a balance sheet of your life. Ultimately, the decision is only yours.

Published: 09-02-2019 07:00

I have no regret even for a day leaving Nepal. It's not that I don't love my country but people are just pathetic and corruption everywhere. Worked there for a few years and was never happy. To me, culture, family etc are important but able to provide a safe environment to my descendant is more important.
It all depends on person to person and their needs. I don't blame or support anyone leaving the US for Nepal because each of us living our own life and has unique needs. So just try to be happy wherever you are.

i can so relate to this. no matter what life in nepal is way easier and safer than in america. I think rape, murders and other crimes happens more over here than in nepal. i have been in usa for 11 years and i always wanted to go home especially after having baby. i hate to see my baby leaving isolated life. No cousins, grandparents, uncle aunts just her sometimes with dad and sometimes with mom. It's even hard for her to see her dad and mom together as me n my husband worked opposite schedule. even though i grew up in third world county i had much better life than my daughter is having right now. we went to Nepal few months before n enjoyed every bit of it. I know we don't even have to work half of what we worked over here to make a decent living in nepal.

नेपाल सुन्दर शान्त विशाल थियो होला महकबी देवकोटा को पाला मा I तर आज नेपाल फर्किने उपाय : कि कालो धन को भण्डार हुनु पर्यो , नत्र भ्रस्ट नेता को आफन्त वा कुखुरा पालन गर्नु पर्यो I अरबौ आप्रवासी आएर सफलता पुर्वक जीवन बिताउदै आएको यस मुलुक मा मैले मात्र कै गर्न नसकेर "मेरो देश मेरो देश" भन्दै फर्किए भने धिक्कार हुनेछ मलाई

This issue of remorse of living away from nepal sounds like the case of grass is always greener on the other side. While in nepal we so pine to step out of nepal..to step out of financial struggles, to show off, to get away from social disarray and other reasons.. We try so hard to show ourselves better than others by dressing up in "modern" clothes, eating out at those fancy restaurants, and so on...

Then after we come to the "land of our dreams" we forget all those factors and start missing cousins, "ethnic" food, culture as if we really hugged it when we were in nepal.

Also, something to note here - whoever 'returns' to Nepal, they don't actually fully return. They still retain their citizenship, green card or at least leave some family members back here (as a backup and the sponsor for potential future immigration) . They know very well this country offers them better medical care, better education and 'stronger' passport and they are in complete love with all these amenities wholeheartedly. They are just confused on what really is more important to them - family, culture, festivals or better opportunities (this can be argued) for their kids. Like she said, it is case by case scenario, some have solid foundation back home, some don't, some have good 'connections' back home, some don't, some will live more comfortable life back home, some won't.

My point is if you did make up your mind to go back, that is not an unselfish decision either. If you are going back it is because you couldn't cope with the fast lifestyle and high work ethics of United States. So, no need to portray yourselves as patriotic selfless Nepali just because you 'returned' back to your country.

Hard choice yet the best choice you will ever make in your life! No regrets always happiness till you die. Make the right choice.

I went back after 10 years with my 2 an half year old. In my honest opinion, things were not the same as they used to be. Well, it wasn't at least for me. We had our wedding here, so it was the first time that I was living with my in-laws in their house. My in-laws didn't like the idea of me wanting to live with my parents for few days which was totally not fair as I had gone for my brother's wedding and wanted to help my mother with wedding preparations.
Speaking about social life, people are more isolated and I could not find the kind of intimacy and bonding between the families/relatives as it used to be before. You will never hear praises for the good things you have done in your life, (may be a few will let you know), rather you will be criticized a lot for leaving your country and parents. I was even asked by one of them why my daughter is dark skinned inspite of living in America (seriously?!). They were very judgemental and would not leave any chance to point something wrong. People are more into show offs. At my brother's wedding, I was highly criticized by my own family members for not wearing enough gold and was questioned if I and my husband weren't doing too well in the states. Nobody would believe me that I had one of the highest paying jobs in US just because I didn't have enough gold or diamonds.
Apart from that, everything is so expensive. People who have money spend it like anything; birthday parties in expensive hotels and what not...there is competition for who spends how much on weddings and bratabandhas. And good schools in Nepal are too expensive. My friend who sends his son to one of the top schools in Kathmandu told me that he spends about Rs. 60000 on his tuition and books.
I do miss my country and my parents a lot but three months of time was enough for me to decide where I would like to spend my life. Everyone's situation is different but I didn't feel nice living in an environment with so much social pressure and constraints. Being judged for your every actions and choices is not what I would want to deal with when there are so many things to focus on in life.

This is what happens after staying in Amrika for 10 , 15 and 20 years- you lose your mind and become a Pakhe.

I am just stating my views. I am sure some will relate and some will not. Totally depends on what you want in your life and your status here. And I haven't lost (loose?) my mind. In fact, I have become more sensible, reasonable, and independent person due to my education and experience in AMRIKA.

@abhilasha_pokhara

ल्वाल

@ Abhilasha_pokhara, totally relate to your experience and thanks for sharing that.

Not saying Nepal was better before. It is arguably better off now politically and economically - still booming real estate, more roads and bridges, more global franchises, new businesses, better buildings etc. The problem, however, is with the ever widening wealth inequality. A few have grown insanely rich and poor are living unimaginable lives. This gap have brought new sets of problems - growing distance between neighbors, families and villagers as everyone is running after money. It is basically a show off versus bitterness or jealousy culture now. This is bound to happen in any capitalistic society though. Nepal is going through that phase and heading towards the individualism of the rich countries. It is not fair, I guess, to expect Nepal and Nepalis to remain nice and innocent while expecting them to be better off economically.

Overall, Nepal is still a male dominated, caste infested and socially ultra-conservative society. It is the culture that some of our Nepalis think they miss the most, but its the culture itself that you would find hard time adjusting to when you go back to Nepal. Yes, in terms of culture and values, Nepal has a long way to go still.

Nepal is screwed up because the society puts more value in wealth and power of a person than his or her role in the society. This is the main reason for exodus of intellectual population from nepal.

Whoever has returned to Nepal and planning to return. Your decision. Good and Bravo!
Whoever has No plan to return Nepal and stay here in USA. Your choice. Must be good and fair one.
Everyone calls me STUPID for having my baby born in Nepal while I have a choice to have my baby here . Nope, I do not and wouldn't regret that decision of mine. The happiness and bond I can see and feel between my mother, father and my baby, it's just beautiful.
अहिले पनि जब नेपाल जान्छु. तेही बाबुको घरमा बस्छु. आमाले बनाको खान्छु. (She cooks amazing food. She is my Gordon Ramsay)
siblings संग अहिले पनि ठाकठुक पर्छ and I always love them.
I feel immense lucky to have wonderful parents and family.
Love Nepal and Have special place for this country in my heart.
नेपाल फर्के पनि येहा बसे पनि, I I wish and prefer to be doing such that would grant me, family and things i love; 'SERENITY'

I have people from South Korea and many rich Chinese at my workplace. They still want to stay here. I do not want to move to Nepal for three main reasons.

1) Hard to get laid
2) Hard to make money
3) Hard to breathe (due to pollution)

ल्वाल. Why South Koreans and Rich Chinese don’t want to go back? Because they can’t show off like in Amrika back in their communist country.

They can show off all they want. China and South Korea are perfectly capitalist countries. They just don't want to be near family and overcrowding back home.

It's an interesting discussion !!

I don't judge people's decision because, there is no RIGHT or WRONG decisions when it comes to heart and feelings.

ल्वाल! देव आनन्दजी को पहिलो युटूबे भिडिओ बिनाको टिप्पणी पढ्न पाउँदा हर्ष न बिस्मात भो | क्यारनी